A Taste of Columbus: Iconic Dishes and Where to Try Them
Columbus, Ohio, is a city known for its diverse culinary scene. From classic comfort foods to innovative creations, Columbus offers a wide range of iconic dishes that every foodie should try. This guide will take you through the iconic dishes in Columbus and where to find them.
Classic Comfort Foods
The Thurmanator: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: The Thurmanator is a legendary burger from The Thurman Café in the German Village. This massive burger features two 12-ounce patties, ham, bacon, cheddar, and American cheese, topped with lettuce, tomato, pickles, banana peppers, and mayo.
Tips: Bring a hearty appetite, as the Thurmanator is not for the faint of heart. Pair it with a local craft beer for the ultimate experience.
Where to Try: The Thurman Café , German Village.
Nearby Attractions: Schiller Park, German Village Society, Book Loft.
Schmidt’s Sausage Haus: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Schmidt’s Sausage Haus is famous for its Bahama Mama, a spicy smoked sausage served with sauerkraut and potato salad. This iconic dish has been a Columbus staple for over a century.
Tips: Don’t miss their jumbo cream puffs for dessert. Visit during the annual Oktoberfest for a festive experience.
Where to Try: Schmidt’s Sausage Haus, German Village.
Nearby Attractions: German Village Society, Schiller Park, Brewery District.
Pizza in Columbus
Rubino’s Pizza: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Rubino’s Pizza has been a beloved institution in Bexley since 1954. Known for its thin-crust pizza, Rubino’s has maintained its original recipes and charm for decades. The restaurant’s iconic status is cemented in Columbus history, even being mentioned in the book “Be True to Your School,” where the author nostalgically orders a pizza during the 1994 graduation ceremony.
Tips: Order the classic pepperoni pizza to experience Rubino’s unique style. The thin crust and generous toppings make it a must-try. Visit with friends and family for a cozy and nostalgic dining experience.
Where to Try: Rubino’s Pizza, Bexley.
Nearby Attractions: Franklin Park Conservatory and Botanical Gardens, Main Street Bexley, Jeffrey Mansion and Park.
Innovative Creations
Hot Chicken Takeover: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Hot Chicken Takeover offers Nashville-style hot chicken, a spicy fried chicken dish that has become a local favorite. Served with pickles, bread, and house-made sides, this dish packs a flavorful punch.
Tips: Choose your spice level wisely, and don’t forget to try the mac and cheese and coleslaw.
Where to Try: Hot Chicken Takeover, North Market and other locations.
Nearby Attractions: North Market, Goodale Park, Short North Arts District.
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams is known for its unique and artisanal flavors. From salty caramel to brambleberry crisp, Jeni’s offers a variety of inventive ice cream options made with high-quality ingredients.
Tips: Sample a few flavors before deciding, and try their ice cream sandwiches and sorbets.
Where to Try: Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams, multiple locations across Columbus.
Nearby Attractions: Short North Arts District, Columbus Commons, Franklin Park Conservatory and Botanical Gardens.
Local Favorites
Buckeye Donuts: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Buckeye Donuts has been a staple near Ohio State University since 1969. Their namesake Buckeye donut, a chocolate and peanut butter treat, is a nod to Ohio’s state tree and a local favorite.
Tips: Visit any time, as Buckeye Donuts is open 24/7. Pair your donut with their fresh coffee for a perfect treat.
Where to Try: Buckeye Donuts, near Ohio State University.
Nearby Attractions: Ohio Stadium, Ohio State University campus, Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum.
Northstar Café: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Northstar Café is beloved for its Northstar Burger, a veggie burger made from organic black beans, brown rice, and beets. It’s served with white cheddar, kale, tomato, pickle, and onion on a toasted bun.
Tips: Visit for brunch to enjoy their delicious breakfast offerings, including the Cloud Nine Pancakes.
Where to Try: Northstar Café, multiple locations across Columbus.
Nearby Attractions: Easton Town Center, Short North Arts District, Columbus Commons.
Sweet Treats
Pistacia Vera: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Pistacia Vera is a patisserie in German Village known for its exquisite French pastries. Their macarons, tarts, and croissants are not to be missed.
Tips: Visit for brunch and enjoy their quiche and coffee. Take home a box of assorted macarons for a delightful treat.
Where to Try: Pistacia Vera, German Village.
Nearby Attractions: Schiller Park, Book Loft, German Village Society.
Fox in the Snow Café: Iconic Dish in Columbus
Description: Fox in the Snow Café is known for its rustic pastries and excellent coffee. Their buttermilk biscuit sandwiches and custard-filled donuts are especially popular.
Tips: Arrive early, as this café can get busy, especially on weekends. Enjoy your pastry with a perfectly brewed coffee.
Where to Try: Fox in the Snow Café , multiple locations across Columbus.
Nearby Attractions: Short North Arts District, Franklin Park Conservatory and Botanical Gardens, Ohio State University campus.
Conclusion
Columbus offers a diverse culinary scene with iconic dishes that reflect the city’s unique flavors and cultural influences. Whether you’re craving classic comfort foods, innovative creations, or sweet treats, this guide will help you discover the best places to experience the iconic dishes in Columbus. Enjoy your culinary adventure in this vibrant city!
